Eric Ramsay rarely airs public criticisms on a certain game’s officiating. Minnesota United head coach almost always tells reporters postgame he will first take another look at a given sequence before sharing his opinion.
But Ramsay didn’t need to rewind footage of Monday’s MLS Cup Playoffs match against Seattle to share his view on whether Sounders defender Jackson Ragen pushed Loons forward Bongi Hlongwane in the ninth minute. In the box on a breakaway, Ragen’s hand connected with Hlongwane’s back; Hlongwane’s shot went wide left as he fell to the grass.
“As clear cut a penalty as I’ve seen not given over the course of this year,” Ramsay said. “I’d be amazed if 99 referees out of 100 don’t look at that for five seconds and think that’s a penalty. It’s a real shame, in a sense, because you have to be able to trust officials in those moments that you’re going to get stuff like that, particularly with VAR these days.”
The ninth-minute no call from referee Alexis Da Silva loomed large — especially in a potential red-card situation for a denial of a goal-scoring opportunity — and how Seattle and Minnesota played 90 scoreless minutes at Allianz Field.
In the end, MNUFC edged Sounders 3-2 in a penalty kick shootout, giving United a 1-0 lead in the best-of-three series. Game 2 is Monday in Seattle.
“I’m glad I can stand here as the winning coach because, with that not being the case, that would have been a real tough pill to swallow.” Ramsay added.
Ramsay might face a fine from MLS for these criticisms.
The Professional Referee Organization (PRO) responded to two written questions on the situation, saying “level of force was not enough to warrant a foul, and (Hlongwane) had a clear opportunity to shoot on goal. The contact did not rise to the level of a penalty kick and red card offense.”
PRO said Video Assistant Referee (VAR) “did not see a clear and obvious error with the on-field decision, (so) there was no (further) review recommended” to Da Silva on the field.
For how measured Ramsay has been across his two seasons in charge, he previously critiqued Da Silva when he officiated the U.S. Open Cup seminal in September. He was critical of how Austin FC’s winger Osman Bukari was not given a red card for kicking Loons defender Anthony Markanich in the Loons’ 2-1 loss.
Given how that decision came in a loss, it stung more. “It was as clear as could possibly be,” Ramsay said in September. “I feel like that is one that we will rue and question. I’m sure we will lose some sleep over that one.”
On Monday after the no-call on Ragen, Loons goalkeeper Dayne St. Clair was issued a yellow card for dissent for a verbal exchange with Da Silva. St. Clair said he was calling for consistency.
“It’s hard as a player because you don’t know what’s a foul and what’s not,” St. Clair said. “You are trying to (walk) the line. Some of them are judgement calls, but especially early on you want to kind of know.
“You push a player in the back, it’s not an attempt at the ball, so it would be a red card as well, which would obviously be a huge advantage.”
The Loons were whistled for four fouls before the no-call on Ragen. In the end, Minnesota players were issued five yellow cards, while no Seattle players were booked. Across the match, Seattle committed 16 fouls to 11 for Minnesota.



