Other voices: Government incompetence is keeping kids out of college

posted in: Society | 0

President Joe Biden’s botched rollout of a revamped financial aid form reveals a stunning lack of managerial competence. It has left colleges unable to tell millions of students how much they’ll have to pay, causing some to delay enrolling and others to drop the idea altogether. This easily avoidable failure threatens to deprive low-income Americans of a college education. And Biden, the country’s chief executive, needs to hold to account the officials who are directly responsible.

The mess stems from the congressionally mandated overhaul of the Free Application for Federal Student Aid, or FAFSA, a form used to determine eligibility for government grants and loans. Once verified by the Education Department, student records are shared with colleges, which then inform students of their tuition costs based on the financial assistance they can expect. In past years, the FAFSA form — with more than 100 questions demanding more data than a tax return — discouraged many low-income students from completing the application, denying them thousands in grant money. In December 2020, Congress told the department to design something simpler.

The work took more than three years and cost $336 million — and the results have been disastrous. Launch delays and various technical snafus caused FAFSA completion rates to plummet by 40%. Despite having only half as many questions, the shorter form has somehow managed to be even more confusing. College counseling groups say it’s taking applicants twice as long to fill out.

The government is now months behind in sending student records to schools and state financial aid agencies. Many colleges aren’t expected to provide estimated aid packages until the summer, leaving families little time to weigh their options. Lacking a clear idea of expected costs, poorer students are less likely to enroll. That would exacerbate the post-pandemic drop in college enrollment — already at a two-decade low — and threaten the survival of dozens of cash-strapped institutions.

To call the government’s performance pathetic would be an understatement. Congressional Republicans have planned hearings on whether Biden’s misguided focus on student loan debt forgiveness distracted officials from fixing the FAFSA — a policy that, unlike the administration’s debt cancellation push, has actually been approved by bipartisan majorities in Congress. A thorough probe of this mismanagement is certainly warranted, as is a broader review of the federal government’s chronic inability to make basic upgrades to its technology.

But lawmakers should go further.

Authorizing the Internal Revenue Service to calculate families’ eligibility for aid when they file their tax returns would save a ton of paperwork and give students more time to plan. And there’s no reason why students from households that already qualify for means-tested federal benefits, such as food stamps, should have to submit the same information to the government twice. Ideally, Congress should order the Education Department to use income tax data to calculate students’ aid eligibility and give that information to colleges and students directly, phasing out the stand-alone FAFSA entirely. Research has shown that simplifying the financial aid process for low-income students can significantly boost their chances of starting and completing college.

There’s growing skepticism about the value of traditional college degrees, so it bears repeating that higher education remains a sound investment and tool of economic mobility for disadvantaged students. The government — including the president — should be making access easier, not getting in the way.

— The Bloomberg Opinion editorial board

Related Articles

Opinion |


Jamelle Bouie: Is the president above the law? The answer is no.

Opinion |


South Dakota governor, a potential Trump running mate, writes in new book about killing her dog

Opinion |


Stephen L. Carter: Should Donald Trump’s jury really remain anonymous?

Opinion |


James Stavridis: Ukraine just got $61 billion. Here’s what it should buy

Opinion |


Zeynep Tufekci: This may be our last chance to halt bird flu in humans and we’re blowing it

Lisa Jarvis: Idaho’s abortion ban is based on legal delusion and medical myth

posted in: Society | 0

On Wednesday, a divided Supreme Court listened to arguments over a state’s abortion ban — its first such hearing since the justices overturned Roe v. Wade. The case, in which the Joe Biden administration is challenging Idaho’s abortion ban, literally puts the health and even the lives of pregnant women on the line.

The Biden administration is arguing that Idaho’s abortion ban should not supersede a 1980s-era federal law called EMTALA (Emergency Medical Treatment & Labor Act), which was designed to prevent hospitals from turning away poor or uninsured patients. The law was passed to stem a growing tide of patients being refused treatment. Under EMTALA, hospitals must stabilize someone whose life is at risk, including if it means terminating a pregnancy that puts them in immediate danger.

Saving a pregnant woman’s life sounds like a no-brainer, yet Idaho’s draconian abortion law only allows an abortion to be performed if it prevents the mother’s death, but not to protect her health. That puts doctors in the unfathomable position of deciding when a woman has teetered close enough to death that they aren’t breaking the law by treating her. If those doctors are later judged to have been too proactive, they could lose their medical licenses and even go to jail.

That has had a chilling effect on women’s health care in Idaho and beyond. Pregnant women have been turned away from hospitals across the country because they aren’t yet far enough over the precipice — maybe their blood pressure is dangerously high, but not yet life-threatening. Maybe they have an infection but have yet to show signs of sepsis.

And in Idaho, doctors fearful of prosecution are airlifting women to neighboring states. One of the state’s hospital systems has reportedly flown six pregnant women to other states since January. Some Idaho doctors are recommending that their pregnant patients buy insurance that covers emergency air transportation.

Yet several of the conservative justices seemed less worried about the potential for women to die and more concerned about how EMTALA could be used to undermine states’ rights. The discussion sometimes drifted into scenarios that are either extremely unusual situations or are pure fabrications meant to stoke concerns that striking down the law would create loopholes in abortion bans.

For example, U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar had to frequently remind the conservative members of the court that in most of these emergencies, doctors are not making a choice between saving the mom and saving her baby — when a pregnancy takes such a dark turn, the baby is often not going to survive. She also had to remind them that in cases where the baby has a chance of survival, the the usual medical advice is to deliver the baby early, not to perform a late-term abortion.

Then there’s the medical myth, raised by the Idaho’s attorney Joshua Turner and probed by Justice Samuel Alito, that if this law wasn’t upheld, someone in a mental health crisis could show up at an emergency room asking for and receive an abortion. As Preloger noted, terminating the pregnancy in such a scenario would be “incredibly unethical” and wouldn’t address the underlying issue, which is one of brain chemistry.

Waiting to treat a woman in crisis could have serious consequences. Waiting to provide care could cause a woman to lose her fertility. She could end up with kidney or neurological damage. She will be doubly traumatized — by the unavoidable loss of an often much-wanted pregnancy and by the completely avoidable experience of being denied care. And of course, if doctors cut it too close, women could die.

As Prelogar succinctly put it, “It just stacks tragedy upon tragedy.”

The impact of laws like Idaho’s extends far beyond the pregnancies where something goes seriously wrong. They encourage doctors to leave the state. A recent analysis of publicly available data by the Idaho Coalition for Safe Healthcare, led by a group of local doctors, found that the state lost 22% of its practicing obstetricians in the 15 months after its abortion ban went into effect. Meanwhile, two hospital OB programs have closed, one more is expected to close, and another is at risk of closing, the group said. That has left half of the state’s counties without a practicing obstetrician. That’s a predicament several other states could find themselves in if the court allows Idaho’s ban to stand.

Ruling in favor of Idaho could also affect states where abortion care is legal. Healthcare systems in neighboring states will need to be prepared to absorb their patients, of course. But it could also encourage Catholic hospital networks, which treat one out of every seven patients in the U.S., to use the law to take a tougher stance against terminating pregnancies that threaten the life of the mother.

As I’ve written before, bans like Idaho’s don’t obviate the need for abortion care. They only pretend that need doesn’t exist. The health impact of these draconian bans is unambiguous, and flies in the face of good medicine.

Lisa Jarvis is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering biotech, health care and the pharmaceutical industry. Previously, she was executive editor of Chemical & Engineering News.

Related Articles

Opinion |


Jamelle Bouie: Is the president above the law? The answer is no.

Opinion |


Stephen L. Carter: Should Donald Trump’s jury really remain anonymous?

Opinion |


James Stavridis: Ukraine just got $61 billion. Here’s what it should buy

Opinion |


Zeynep Tufekci: This may be our last chance to halt bird flu in humans and we’re blowing it

Opinion |


Adam Minter: The cost of youth baseball rises and rises — and prices many kids out

For-profit packing plants in Little Canada, St. Paul and Roseville support a nonprofit for the blind which teaches visually impaired life skills

posted in: News | 0

When he started going blind 20 years ago at the age of 41, Fernando Amigon turned to Vision Loss Resources for guidance. The nonprofit offers a full suite of classes for the visually impaired, teaching everything from basic home cooking and cleaning to braille instruction and computer skills.

Amigon eventually found work with Contract Production Services, VLR’s sister company, a for-profit packing plant that employs workers to insert everyday retail items into the packaging customers see on store shelves.

The company, which maintains an 86,000-square-foot packing warehouse adjoining the VLR offices in Little Canada, has been his home away from home for much of the last two decades. So much so that tactile guidance strips on the floor lead from his work station to the bathroom and break room.

“I used to be able to see lamp light,” said Amigon in Spanish on Tuesday, as he inserted 3M respirators into their cardboard and plastic casings at a clipped pace. “For six years, it’s been nothing, nothing, nothing.”

Comprehensive institute for the blind

Instructor Jenny Stenner, left, talks with Lauren Holecko, who is deaf and blind, using tactile signing in a classroom at Vision Loss Resources in Little Canada on Tuesday, April 23, 2024. (John Autey / Pioneer Press)

When Minneapolis-based Blind Inc. shut its doors last December after 38 years in operation, Vision Loss Resources became the Twin Cities metro’s only comprehensive institute for the blind. That’s led to an uptick in clients for VLR, which only recently relocated from Minneapolis but is already on the verge of outgrowing the suburban office and factory floor space it acquired off Interstate 694 and Interstate 35E in 2022.

Together with a sister nonprofit, DeafBlind Services Minnesota, VLR serves upwards of 200 vision-impaired clients per year in a training setting some might liken to a small community college, helping to ready both the newly blind and long-standing visually impaired for an ever-changing world.

“It’s almost like you’re getting an associate’s degree in independent living,” said Matt Kramer, who became president and chief executive officer a year ago of both nonprofits and the for-profit packing operation that helps sustain them. “How do you know what the stove is set at? How do you run a washer-dryer? These are real courses. We have real class periods.”

From typing class to braille

According to the American Foundation for the Blind, some 85,000 to 92,000 Minnesotans report vision difficulty, meaning they have trouble seeing even when wearing glasses, if they can see at all.

Matt Kramer, CEO and president of Vision Loss Resources (VLR) in Little Canada, on Tuesday, April 23, 2024. (John Autey / Pioneer Press)

In VLR’s technology class, the goal is to get visually-impaired students to type at 30 words per minute. Instructor Shawn Bangsund never touches a mouse or turns on his computer screen as he scrolls its icons, whose names are read aloud to him at a rapid pace by screen-reading software.

He slows the reader down for the sake of a reporter, but he’s accustomed to it describing what’s on the unlit screen before him at a speed that most would find unfathomable.

“For the average person, it’s just gibberish,” said Bangsund, with a laugh. “I never have to worry about the average person overhearing what I’m typing.”

In a small training room around the corner, braille instructor Melody Wartenbee guides two students in how to read books using a computer-assisted braille display. Wartenbee, who described herself as a prolific reader of nonfiction, quips that she’s “20/20 blind,” or completely blind since birth. Still, there are others with even more fundamental challenges, requiring the help of two additional instructors to teach a student who is both legally deaf and blind using hands-on communication.

Instructor Shawn Bangsund, who has been blind since birth, listens to a program that reads the contents of his computer to him, thus he doesn’t need his monitor to be on, while in his classroom at Vision Loss Resources in Little Canada on Tuesday, April 23, 2024. (John Autey / Pioneer Press)

In yet another training room, Paul Hall took advice from instructor Lauren Chuba, a former VLR student who went on to become a public school teacher before returning to the nonprofit as an educator.

“I’m just trying to get back to the older version of me,” said Hall, who has been using VLR services, off and on, since 1992. A former motorcycle rider, he now navigates unfamiliar corners with the help of a cane. He can see shapes, but has no depth perception or peripheral vision, he said, and he relies on a smartphone camera reader to identify store items.

In addition to classes, VLR offers a support group to help the newly blind cope with what they’ve lost and understand the new community they may be gaining. Clients have arrived with blindness associated with traumatic brain injuries, stroke and even a gunshot wound to the eye.

“Vision loss is traumatic,” said Kramer, a former president and CEO of the St. Paul Area Chamber of Commerce. “Generally speaking, it doesn’t come back.”

A top packing producer for the Midwest

Kramer noted that VLR’s contracts with the state, which are largely based on reimbursements for lessons taught, only go so far, especially when some 30% of students miss class, which he called a near-inevitability with a vulnerable population.

To make up funding, VLR relies on Contract Production Services, which maintains nearly 150,000 square feet of warehouse packing or staging space in Little Canada, St. Paul and Roseville.

“We’re easily one of the top producers for packing in the Midwest,” Kramer said.

Dozens of workers, most of them Central American immigrants, place retail items into consumer-facing packaging, which are then trucked to Target, Amazon and Walmart warehouses, among other distribution centers, for eventual sale across North America.

Amigon, who has spent a total of 13 years working for Contract Production Services off and on, is the company’s only visually-impaired employee, and a key reminder to workers and trainers alike of the mission they’re there to support.

While some other nonprofits offer classes for the blind in particular skillsets, VLR is the only remaining nonprofit in the Twin Cities that offers what Kramer described as a “comprehensive suite” of life skills training, he said. Before Blind Inc. closed its doors on Jan. 1, VLR saw some 20 to 25 clients per month, in settings where one-on-one instruction is often essential. That’s grown overnight to at least 30 clients, and as many as 40 clients in a single month. The combined annual budget for the two nonprofits is about $2 million.

Blind Inc.

Workers assemble and pack items for customers at the Vision Loss Resources’ Contract Production Services facility in Little Canada on Tuesday, April 23, 2024. (John Autey / Pioneer Press)

In a public statement last December, Blind Inc. blamed its sudden closure, in part, on its inability to keep up with the “millions of dollars in renovations” needed at its headquarters, the historic Pillsbury mansion in Minneapolis, which “must be done in a manner that preserves its historic character.”

The nonprofit said it was working with the National Federation of the Blind to hopefully reopen.

“The Blind Inc. situation is supposed to be a temporary pause in services,” said Chris Danielsen, a spokesman for the federation, on Wednesday. “They didn’t know exactly when they planned to reopen. They’re trying to figure out a path forward.”

Not every student at VLR is visually impaired. In a teaching kitchen, Nyia Vang, a new administrative assistant to the director of the State Services for the Blind, wears vision-altering simulator goggles that allow her to experience the challenge of completing basic everyday tasks with a kind of tunnel vision.

On Tuesday, her second day of training, Vang successfully made a sandwich and a smoothie.

There were some unnerving moments along the way, “especially when I had to wear the blindfolds and walk upstairs,” said Vang, who will complete four weeks of training before returning to state offices, where she’ll help connect the visually impaired to similar types of instructional services.

Related Articles

Local News |


Annual Stillwater plant sale set for May 18

Local News |


Activist Brittany Packnett Cunningham to speak at Minneapolis Teach for America event

Local News |


Peñaloga tapped to be Basic Needs’ new executive director

Local News |


Emily Blomberg named president of Regions Hospital and the Regions Hospital Foundation

Local News |


‘Is Minneapolis good?’ How a Russian transgender refugee found hope in Minnesota — and a friend at the airport

Concert review: Nicki Minaj lit up Target Center whenever she was on stage

posted in: News | 0

The sold-out crowd Saturday night at Minneapolis’ Target Center was ready and waiting for Nicki Minaj. In the 14 years since the Trinidadian rapper/singer first broke through, she’s become the best-selling female hip-hop star in the world while maintaining side gigs acting in films and succeeding as an entrepreneur.

Somewhat shockingly, the Pink Friday 2 World Tour is Minaj’s first U.S. tour in nearly a decade and Saturday served as Minaj’s debut headlining a Twin Cities arena. Those facts brought an extra charge to the audience, many of whom wore pink, Minaj’s favorite color. With all of that waiting, well, perhaps Minaj thought they could wait a little bit longer.

Despite an advertised start time of 8 p.m., Minaj didn’t take the stage until 10:10 p.m. in the noticeably stuffy basketball arena. If that sounds familiar, it’s also the way Madonna does it. One could make the argument that a musical act with the outsized success of Madonna, or Minaj, makes it worth it.

Well, Minaj delivered a top-notch show with more than 30 songs along with fog, fire, lights and a massive stage that served double duty as a screen flashing custom animations throughout. Even with all that razzle and dazzle, Minaj commanded the attention, and devotion, of the crowd — when she was actually on stage, that is.

For all the attention clearly paid to the concert’s visual presentation and its generous set list, somebody forgot about pacing. In order to facilitate Minaj’s many costume changes, a series of lengthy interludes brought the momentum to a screeching halt. During the first hour, every time it seemed like Minaj was really hitting her stride, one of four interludes interrupted, each seemingly longer than the one before.

After a mini set of songs that showcased her singing, Minaj ceded the stage to her “opening” act Monica. While the R&B vocalist’s time in the spotlight fell way back in the latter half of the ’90s, her voice has more than just held up and her short set had Gen Xers in the audience swooning. When she finished, the crowd had to endure yet another interlude.

Again, when she was on stage, Minaj shined. For much of the evening, she held the posture of royalty, standing in place and making grand gestures with her arms. A backup dancer held her hand and guided her down the two flights of steps whenever she decided it was time to find a new space to rule on the stage.

She didn’t dance as much as one might expect, but when she did, she delivered, like during “Cowgirl” when she swayed seductively flanked by four muscular male dancers in Stetsons. She laid down on the stage and performed “Pink Birthday” writhing and thrusting to the beat and never missing a line. Indeed, Minaj impressed with her fluid, dynamic rapping and her uncanny ability to keep each word distinct, even during the fastest bits.

Minaj noticeably loosened up after the Monica mini-concert when she tore through a run of her biggest hits, including “Super Freaky Girl,” “Anaconda,” “Super Bass” and “Starships.” The latter earned the strongest reaction of the night from the crowd, who walked out glowing, likely to forgive and/or forget about the slow moments.

Related Articles

Music and Concerts |


Concert review: Three decades on and Tim McGraw’s still got it

Music and Concerts |


Concert review: Kane Brown blows up country conventions at Target Center

Music and Concerts |


Prince’s sister Tyka Nelson to retire from performing live with show at the Dakota

Music and Concerts |


New SPCO season will feature musician-curated concerts and Netflix-style memberships

Music and Concerts |


Ludacris and T-Pain added to Minnesota State Fair Grandstand lineup