Ramsey County approves $1.2 million county retiree Medicare Advantage supplement; St. Paul School District votes tonight

posted in: News | 0

The Ramsey County Board voted 5-1 on Tuesday to put $1.2 million toward a supplemental health insurance plan for county retirees, with the goal of maintaining access to HealthPartners hospitals and clinics next year for former county employees subscribed to the UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage program.

The board noted the one-time spending will come from the county’s post-employment benefits fund, which is fueled by a 6% payroll surcharge charged to every county department, but the effort falls far short of a cure-all, given premiums that could in some cases double under the supplemental plan.

With the same goal of ensuring retiree access to Regions Hospital and other HealthPartners sites, the St. Paul Board of Education, or school board, is scheduled to vote Tuesday evening on a $3.5 million contribution toward its own supplemental health insurance plan for UHC Medicare Advantage subscribers.

HealthPartners and UHC continue to be locked in a dispute over claim denials, and HealthPartners informed some 30,000 UHC Medicare Advantage subscribers this summer they will be considered out-of-network in 2025 and not be able to access Regions Hospital and other HealthPartners sites next year unless the dispute is soon resolved. Thousands of city of St. Paul, St. Paul School District and Ramsey County retirees are among those impacted.

Ramsey County Board Chair Victoria Reinhardt and Commissioner Nicole Joy Frethem (Courtesy of Reinhardt and Frethem)

“I don’t feel like we can put our retirees out, hanging out on a limb, because they’re having a fight that we, again, had nothing to do with,” said Ramsey County Board Chair Victoria Reinhardt, a lead proponent of the supplemental plan. “No one should be put in this position.”

She noted that county retirees who opt for the pricier supplemental plan would be able to switch back to the cheaper UHC Medicare Advantage program next year if the two sides come to an agreement by the end of the year.

County Commissioner Nicole Frethem, who cast the sole “No” vote against the $1.2 million county proposal, said the county should instead be dedicating those dollars toward employee benefits for existing workers, rather than rewarding UnitedHealthcare with extra spending. The county is currently in labor negotiations, and benefits are part of that discussion, she noted.

“I have concerns. I could see an action going two ways. It could reassure our employees we will keep with the spirit of our commitments … or it could make a challenging (labor) negotiation even harder,” Frethem said.

Cheapest option isn’t always the best

Frethem said her own uncle had complained to her that the county had not stepped up to protect retiree health insurance benefits.

She said that perception was wrong — the county was unfairly roped into an ongoing dispute between a health system and a for-profit insurer.

“I am really frustrated that we could be spending up to $1.2 million, that we could be spending on our current employees, to bail out UHC and HealthPartners,” she said. “Why is it not UHC’s responsibility to provide that breach in coverage? … You need to work it out. Put on your big kid pants and work it out. … This is not an easy decision.”

Frethem and other members of the county board urged state lawmakers to get involved and promote a public healthcare option.

County Commissioner Rafael Ortega said the supplemental option is “not perfect, but given the stories that some of the retirees are facing serious health issues, it’s not just a matter of changing doctors. They’re in the middle of treatment.”

He said the county should look for a new health insurance vendor in early 2025, and the cheapest option might not be the best one.

“Quite frankly, we went with the lowest bidder as part of our criteria, and we really need to look at that in the future,” Ortega said. “I think the first thing we do next year is put out a (request for proposals).”

On Monday, a spokesperson for HealthPartners said negotiations with UnitedHealthcare were still underway. A spokesperson for UnitedHealthcare released a written statement on Tuesday making similar claims, but no further information.

“We are currently engaged in good-faith negotiation with HealthPartners,” reads the unsigned statement from UnitedHealthcare. “Our goal is to renew our relationship and ensure continued, uninterrupted network access to the health system. We hope HealthPartners continues to engage with us and work toward a new agreement.”

Related Articles

Local News |


Ice Castles moving to the State Fairgrounds this year

Local News |


Ramsey County, St. Paul School District weigh fixes for UnitedHealth impasse with HealthPartners, but votes unclear

Local News |


Food scrap pickup program expands to 19 new Washington County communities

Local News |


Circumstantial evidence at issue as Nicholas Firkus murder conviction goes to appeal

Local News |


High school football: Mounds View beats East Ridge to clinch share of sub-district title

Hurricane Milton to balloon into wide storm before catastrophic Florida landfall within 36 hours

posted in: Society | 0

Residents along Florida’s Gulf coast near Tampa Bay are being urged to complete their storm preparations today — or evacuate if necessary — as Hurricane Milton barrels toward the state with “the potential to be one of the most destructive hurricanes on record” for Florida within 36 hours, National Hurricane Center forecasters said.

Overnight, Milton went through an eyewall replacement in the Gulf of Mexico, something which typically happens in large hurricanes and results in the storm’s wind field expanding and its power dropping. Just prior to the replacement, Milton had intensified at an astonishing rate and barometric pressure had plunged below 900 millibars, making it one of the top five most intense Atlantic hurricanes on record.

Top sustained winds as of 11 a.m. Monday morning were 150 mph, still a catastrophic Category 4 but down from the Monday night peak of 180. Forecasters said Milton’s intensity may continue to fluctuate up or down over the Gulf of Mexico’s deep, warm waters.

The exact forecast track remains in flux. As of Tuesday morning, landfall is forecast to be just south of Tampa Bay, but the cone of uncertainty stretches from the Gulf Hammock Wildlife park south to Captiva Island. A direct or near-direct hit on Tampa Bay could bring storm surge of 12-15 feet. The mayor of Tampa told residents that such a surge would be “unsurvivable” to those who ignore evacuation orders.

After landfall, the forecast shows Milton tracking parallel to Interstate 4, passing just south of Orlando, and exiting the state’s Space Coast. Regardless of where the storm hits directly, Milton will have a very large wind field by landfall and much of the central portion of Florida is at risk of flash flooding, destructive wind and possible tornadoes.

As of 11 a.m., Hurricane Milton was located about 520 miles west-southwest of Tampa, moving east-northeast at 9 mph. Hurricane-force winds extend outward up to 30 miles from the center, and tropical-storm-force winds extend outward up to 105 miles from the center.

Tampa Bay has not endured a direct hit from a hurricane in more than a century. If the track holds and Milton remains a major hurricane, the storm surge in the region would be catastrophic, forecasters said.

Here’s the forecast track for Hurricane Milton as of 8 a.m. Tuesday (National Hurricane Center)

Forecasters said that although the eyewall replacement that occurred overnight had weakened Milton slightly, that’s not exactly good news. “The eyewall replacement cycle will likely lead to an expansion of the destructive inner core of the hurricane during the next day or two,” the hurricane center said.

Hurricane warnings extend far inland as Milton is forecast to retain hurricane strength during its entire passage east across Central Florida and Orlando, then out into the Atlantic Ocean near Cape Canaveral. South Florida is under a tropical storm watch with high winds from 58 mph to 73 mph and heavy rainfall possible despite being far from Milton’s forecast path.

The Tampa Bay area is still rebounding from Helene and its powerful surge — a wall of water up to 8 feet it created even though its eye was 100 miles offshore. Twelve people died there, with the worst damage along a string of barrier islands from St. Petersburg to Clearwater.

Stragglers were a problem during Helene and 2022’s Ian. Many residents failed to heed ample warnings, saying they evacuated during previous storms only to have major surges not materialize. But there was evidence Monday that people were getting out before Milton arrives.

A steady stream of vehicles headed north toward the Florida Panhandle on Interstate 75 as residents heeded evacuation orders. Traffic clogged the southbound lanes of the highway for miles as other residents headed for the relative safety of South Florida.

“This is a ferocious hurricane,” Gov. Ron DeSantis said Monday. “Anything south of the storm is going to have major storm surge, even 100 miles away.”

“By taking an extremely unusual track across the Gulf slightly farther south than forecast, Milton has a long runway in an atmospheric environment that is forecast to be extremely conducive to strengthening,” said Fox Weather hurricane expert Bryan Norcross. “Unless we get extremely lucky, Milton will be one of the biggest hurricane disasters in history.”

DeSantis pointed out that there was loss of life due to Hurricane Helene two weeks ago, and Milton’s surge looks to be worse. The predicted storm surge is the highest ever forecast for Tampa Bay and nearly double the levels reached two weeks ago during Helene, said National Hurricane Center spokeswoman Maria Torres.

Much of Florida’s west coast is under threat of severe storm surge, with as much as 15 feet forecast for areas around Tampa Bay. (National Hurricane Center)

Many sand dunes and other natural protection were destroyed less than two weeks ago by Hurricane Helene. “That means storm surge impacts from Milton could be even more significant,” said AccuWeather chief meteorologist Jon Porter.

The hurricane center issued a multitude of watches and warnings Monday evening.

A hurricane warning has been issued for the west coast of Florida from Bonita Beach north to the mouth of the Suwannee River, including Tampa Bay.
A tropical storm warning has been issued for the west coast of Florida south of Bonita Beach to Flamingo, including Lake Okeechobee.
There is a tropical storm warning for the Florida Keys, including the Dry Tortugas. A tropical storm watch stretches from Miami-Dade to Port St. Lucie, and another for the coasts of Georgia and South Carolina. There is a hurricane watch from the St. Lucie/Indian River County Line northward to the mouth of the St. Marys River in Georgia.
A storm surge watch has been issued for the U.S. East Coast from Sebastian Inlet to Edisto Beach, South Carolina, including the St. Johns River.
The storm surge warning for the west coast also extends from Flamingo north to the Suwannee River, including Charlotte Harbor and Tampa Bay.

In South Florida, tropical-storm-force winds could arrive by by Wednesday afternoon, the National Weather Service said.

DeSantis said that while it remains to be seen just where Milton will strike, it’s clear that Florida is going to be hit hard: “I don’t think there’s any scenario where we don’t have major impacts at this point.”

The state’s Director of Emergency Management, Kevin Guthrie, said the state is preparing for the largest hurricane evacuation since 2017, when Hurricane Irma cut through the entire length of the Florida peninsula from the Keys to Georgia.

“Please, if you’re in the Tampa Bay area, you need to evacuate,” said Guthrie. “If they have called your evacuation order, I beg you, I implore you, to evacuate. Drowning deaths due to storm surge are 100% preventable if you leave. We had situations where people died drowning in Hurricane Ian. Had they just gone across the bridge, from Estero Bay and Sanibel island … they’d still be alive today.”

It’s the “black swan” worst case scenario that MIT meteorology professor Kerry Emanuel and other hurricane experts have worried about for years.

Part of it is that for some reason — experts say it’s mostly luck with a bit of geography — Tampa hasn’t been hit with a major hurricane since the deadly 1921 hurricane that had 11 feet of storm surge that inundated downtown Tampa, though there wasn’t much to the city at the time, Emanuel said. Since then, a metropolis has grown and it’s full of people who think they’ve lived through big storms when they haven’t, he said.

“It’s a huge population. It’s very exposed, very inexperienced and that’s a losing proposition,” Emanuel, who has studied hurricanes for 40 years, said. “I always thought Tampa would be the city to worry about most.”

Guthrie said that if you  need assistance evacuating, you can call the state’s hotline: 800-729-3413. There’s also a website, fl511.com, for with emergency evacuation information.

State officials said that Visit Florida has emergency accommodation modules on Expedia, Priceline and Booking.com for real-time hotel availability. Uber will also be offering free rides to shelters, as they did during Hurricane Helene. DeSantis said the the state would be issuing a code for Uber shortly.

DeSantis warned that hurricane-force winds will penetrate far inland. “You’re going to have hurricane winds, potentially category 3, but certainly 1 or 2, all the way through the Florida peninsula,” he said.

The state has prepared emergency fuel sources and electric vehicle charging stations along evacuation routes, and “identified every possible location that can possibly house someone along those routes,” Guthrie said. People who live in homes built after Florida strengthened its codes in 2004, who don’t depend on constant electricity and who aren’t in evacuation zones, should probably avoid the roads, he said.

DeSantis stated that crews readying to mobilize for power restoration, and that Milton may cause outages greater than those brought by Hurricane Helene.

There is a “massive amount of resources being marshalled,” he added.

On Monday, the Biden administration approved an Emergency Declaration for Florida, allowing federal disaster assistance for the state through the Federal Emergency Management Agency.

There had been media rumors that DeSantis “declined a call” with Vice President Kamala Harris. DeSantis said that was not true, and that at the time, he didn’t know she had called. He said President Joe Biden has approved everything Florida has asked for. The president and the governor spoke Monday night, the White House said.

Milton is expected to bring rain totals of 5 to 8 inches, with localized areas seeing potentially up to 18 inches, across portions of the central to northern Florida peninsula through Thursday. That will come on top of moisture ahead of the hurricane that is already saturating the state.

“If the center of Milton tracks just to the north of Tampa Bay, the scope of potential storm surge is impossible to imagine,” Norcross wrote on his blog, Hurricane Intel. “Think of of Helene’s surge and add another few feet.”

A flood watch is in effect for all of South Florida into Thursday morning, though all three counties are not in the forecast cone as of Tuesday morning. Broward and Palm Beach county schools will be open Tuesday, but close Wednesday and Thursday, the districts announced on Monday afternoon.

Since many of the counties under the Milton state of emergency are still recovering from Hurricane Helene, DeSantis asked the Florida Division of Emergency Management and the Florida Department of Transportation to coordinate all available resources and personnel to supplement local communities as they expedite debris removal.

As many as 5,000 National Guard troops are helping state crews to remove the tons of debris left behind by Helene, DeSantis said, and he directed that Florida crews dispatched to North Carolina in Helene’s aftermath return to the state to prepare for Milton.

With Milton achieving hurricane status, this is the first time the Atlantic has had three simultaneous hurricanes after September, said Colorado State University hurricane scientist Phil Klotzbach. There have been four simultaneous hurricanes in August and September.

On Monday, the hurricane center said Milton is the third fastest-strengthening hurricane on record in the Atlantic Basin. It grew from a Category 2 on Monday morning to Category 5 by noon. Only Wilma (2005) and Felix (2007) intensified faster. Also, it grew from a tropical storm to a Category 5 hurricane within the span of 36 hours.

Rapid intensification is fueled by hot sea surface temperatures, lack of wind shear as well as the storm’s clean vertical posture. Storms with smaller diameters can more easily ramp up as well.

Other tropical systems

On Monday, a disturbance formed over the Bahamas and has 20% chance of developing in the next 2 days. It is expected to travel northeast, away from Florida.

Far in the Atlantic, Tropical Storm Leslie’s track should keep it away from land, and Kirk has become a powerful extratropical cyclone with a tracked aimed at Spain and France.

Leslie, located 1,435 miles west-northwest of Africa’s southernmost Cabo Verde Islands, had a maximum sustained wind speed of 70 mph and was moving northwest at 13 mph as of 11  a.m. Tuesday.

In addition, the National Hurricane Center is watching a tropical wave that is expected to move off the west coast of Africa in a few days, although the chance of development is low, with a 20% chance through the next seven days.

The next named storm will be Nadine.

Information from the Associated Press was used in this report.

States sue TikTok, claiming its platform is addictive and harms the mental health of children

posted in: News | 0

By HALELUYA HADERO

More than a dozen states and the District of Columbia have filed lawsuits against TikTok on Tuesday, alleging the popular short-form video app is harming youth mental health by designing its platform to be addictive to kids.

The lawsuits stem from a national investigation into TikTok, which was launched in March 2022 by a bipartisan coalition of attorneys general from many states, including New York, California, Kentucky and New Jersey. All of the complaints were filed in state courts.

At the heart of each lawsuit is the TikTok algorithm, which powers what users see on the platform by populating the app’s main “For You” feed with content tailored to people’s interests. The lawsuits also emphasize design features that they say make children addicted to the platform, such as the ability to scroll endlessly through content, push notifications that come with built-in “buzzes” and face filters that create unattainable appearances for users.

In its filings, the District of Columbia called the algorithm “dopamine-inducing,” and said it was created to be intentionally addictive so the company could trap many young users into excessive use and keep them on its app for hours on end. TikTok does this despite knowing that these behaviors will lead to “profound psychological and physiological harms,” such as anxiety, depression, body dysmorphia and other long-lasting problems, the complaint said.

“It is profiting off the fact that it’s addicting young people to its platform,” District of Columbia Attorney General Brian Schwalb said in an interview.

“We strongly disagree with these claims, many of which we believe to be inaccurate and misleading. We’re proud of and remain deeply committed to the work we’ve done to protect teens and we will continue to update and improve our product,” said TikTok spokesman Alex Haurek in a reply to the lawsuits. “We’ve endeavored to work with the Attorneys General for over two years, and it is incredibly disappointing they have taken this step rather than work with us on constructive solutions to industrywide challenges.”

The social media firm does not allow children under 13 to sign up for its main service and restricts some content for everyone under 18. But Washington and several other states said in their filing that children can easily bypass those restrictions, allowing them to access the service adults use despite the company’s claims that its platform is safe for children.

“TikTok claims that is safe for young people, but that is far from true. In New York and across the country, young people have died or gotten injured doing dangerous TikTok challenges and many more are feeling more sad, anxious, and depressed because of TikTok’s addictive features,” New York Attorney General Letitia James said in a statement.

Their lawsuit also takes aim at other parts of the company’s business.

The district alleges TikTok is operating as an “unlicensed virtual economy” by allowing people to purchase TikTok Coins – a virtual currency within the platform – and send “Gifts” to streamers on TikTok LIVE who can cash it out for real money. TikTok takes a 50% commission on these financial transactions but hasn’t registered as a money transmitter with the U.S. Treasury Department or authorities in the district, according to the complaint.

Officials say teens are frequently exploited for sexually explicit content through TikTok’s LIVE streaming feature, which has allowed the app to operate essentially as a “virtual strip club” without any age restrictions. They say the cut the company gets from the financial transactions allows it to profit from exploitation.

The 14 attorneys general say the goal of their lawsuits is to stop TikTok from using these features, impose financial penalties for their alleged illegal practices and collect damages for users that have been harmed.

Many states have filed lawsuits against TikTok and other tech companies over the past few years as a reckoning grows against prominent social media platforms and their ever-growing impact on young people’s lives. In some cases, the challenges have been coordinated in a way that resembles how states previously organized against the tobacco and pharmaceutical industries.

Last week, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sued TikTok, alleging the company was sharing and selling minors’ personal information in violation of a new state law that prohibits these practices. TikTok, which disputes the allegations, is also fighting against a similar data-oriented federal lawsuit filed in August by the Department of Justice.

Several Republican-led states, such as Nebraska, Kansas, New Hampshire, Kansas, Iowa and Arkansas, have also previously sued the company, some unsuccessfully, over allegations it is harming children’s mental health, exposing them to “inappropriate” content or allowing young people to be sexually exploited on its platform. Arkansas has brought a legal challenge against YouTube, as well as Meta Platforms, which owns Facebook and Instagram and is being sued by dozens of states over allegations its harming young people’s mental health. New York City and some public school districts have also brought their own lawsuits.

TikTok, in particular, is facing other challenges at the national level. Under a federal law that took effect earlier this year, TikTok could be banned from the U.S. by mid-January if its China-based parent company ByteDance doesn’t sell the platform by then.

Both TikTok and ByteDance are challenging the law at an appeals court in Washington. A panel of three judges heard oral arguments in the case last month and are expected to issue a ruling, which could be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Thomas Friedman: What I’m thinking about on the first anniversary of the war

posted in: News | 0

So what am I thinking about on this anniversary of the Hamas-Hezbollah-Iran-Israel war? Something my strategy teacher, Prof. John Arquilla of the U.S. Naval Postgraduate School, taught me: All wars come down to two basic questions: Who wins the battle on the ground? And who wins the battle of the story? And what I am thinking about today is how, even after a year of warfare, in which Hamas and Hezbollah and Israel have inflicted terrible pain on one another’s forces and civilians, no one has decisively won the battle on the ground or the battle for the story.

Indeed, one year after Oct. 7, this is still the first Arab-Israeli war without a name and without a clear victor — because neither side has a clear win or a clean story.

We can and should sympathize with Palestinian statelessness and Arabs in the West Bank living under the duress of Israeli settlements and restrictions, but to my mind, there is nothing that can justify what Hamas attackers did on Oct. 7 — murdering, maiming, kidnapping and sexually abusing any Israeli they could get their hands on, without any goal, any story, other than to destroy the Jewish state. If you believe, as I do, that the only solution is two states for two indigenous peoples between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, the Hamas rampage set that back immeasurably.

And what story is Iran telling? That it has some right under the U.N. charter to help create failed states in Lebanon, Syria, Yemen and Iraq so it can cultivate proxies inside them for the purpose of destroying Israel? And by what right has Hezbollah dragged Lebanon into a war with Israel that the Lebanese people and government had no say in and are now paying a huge price for?

But this Israeli government does not have a clean story in the Gaza Strip, either. This was always going to be the ugliest of Israeli-Palestinian wars since 1947, because Hamas had embedded itself in tunnels underneath Gaza homes, schools, mosques and hospitals. It could not be targeted without significant civilian casualties. Therefore, as I argued from the start, it was doubly incumbent on Israel to make clear that this was not just a war to defend itself but also to destroy Hamas in order to birth something better: the only just and stable solution possible, two states for two people.

Related Articles

Opinion |


Adrian Wooldridge: Nanny states are now essential to economic health

Opinion |


Clive Crook: Trump offers voters a trifecta of economic madness

Opinion |


Devin Watkins: The Supreme Court is empowering voters

Opinion |


F.D. Flam: Lock down the cows to prevent further bird flu spread

Opinion |


J. Doyne Farmer: Eager for good news about climate change? Consider the pace of clean energy growth

The Israeli government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu steadfastly has refused to do that, so much so that a year later, it still has not told its people, its army or its U.S. arms supplier what it wants to build in Gaza in place of Hamas other than “total victory.” With Israel still bombing schools to kill a few Hamas fighters hiding inside yet failing to articulate any future for Gaza residents other than permanent war, it feels as though killing every last Hamasnik is the goal — no matter how many civilians die. That’s a forever war that will undermine both Israel and America’s credibility and embarrass Israel’s Arab allies.

But the lack of a good story is hurting Israel in other ways. Israelis are being asked to send their sons and daughters to fight every day against Hamas and Hezbollah foes — yet cannot be sure if they are going to war to save the state of Israel or the political career of their prime minister.

Because there is more than enough reason to believe that Benjamin Netanyahu wants to keep this war going to have an excuse to postpone testifying in December at his corruption trial, to postpone an independent commission of inquiry as to how his government failed to prevent the worst attack on Jews since the Holocaust, as well as to forestall new Israeli elections and maybe even to tilt our presidential election to Donald Trump. Netanyahu’s far-right Jewish supremacist partners have told him they will topple his government if he agrees to stop the war in Gaza before an undefined “total victory” over Hamas and if he tries to bring the West Bank’s Palestinian Authority, which has embraced the Oslo peace process, to help govern Gaza in the place of Hamas — something that Hamas greatly fears.

This absence of a story is also hurting Israel strategically. The more Israel has a legitimate Palestinian partner, like a reformed Palestinian Authority, the better chance it can get out of Gaza and not preside over a permanent insurgency there, the more allies will want to help create an international force to fill any vacuum in southern Lebanon and the more any Israeli military strike against Iran would be understood as making Israel safe to try to make peace with the Palestinians — not safe for an Israeli annexation of the West Bank and Gaza, which is what some of Netanyahu’s far-right partners are seeking.

I cannot guarantee that there is a legitimate Palestinian partner for a secure peace with Israel. But I can guarantee that this Israeli government has done everything it could to prevent one from emerging — by strengthening Hamas in Gaza at the expense of the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank.

It is simply insane to me that the United Arab Emirates is telling Israel that it would send military forces to Gaza to stabilize the peace there, in conjunction with the U.S. and other international forces — and that Saudi Arabia has indicated it is ready to normalize relations with Israel, help pay for Gaza’s reconstruction and open a road for relations between the Jewish state and the whole Muslim world — and yet Netanyahu up to now has said no to both because all of this would require that Israel open talks with a reformed Palestinian Authority on a two-state solution and that this Palestinian Authority would formally invite the UAE and others to help secure Gaza.

And it is disastrous in another way that is not so obvious. Israel has just delivered a devastating blow to Hezbollah’s leadership. As a purely military operation — combining high tech, intelligence and precision strikes by the Israeli Air Force — it will be studied by armies all over the world. But here’s the rub: I can assure you that most of the Israeli pilots, spies and technologists who produced that operation were the same Israeli street protesters and leaders of the opposition to the judicial coup that Netanyahu attempted in the year before the Hamas invasion — a coup attempt that split the country and encouraged Hamas’ invasion and Hezbollah’s pile-on, as Netanyahu was warned before the war.

No one has taught me more about the tension between those pilots’ stories and Bibi’s story — and its implications for Israel’s fate — than Dan Ben-David, a Tel Aviv University economist who heads the Shoresh Institution for Socioeconomic Research. I wrote to him to ask what he was thinking about the Oct. 7 anniversary. This is what he emailed back:

“My mom was a 13-year-old smuggled alone out of Baghdad to Palestine during World War II. My father landed here as an orphan; his father was butchered by his Lithuanian neighbors as the Nazis moved in. Following the war of independence, my parents’ army units joined to create Kibbutz Malkiya on the Lebanese border. (That kibbutz, where they first met and married, became a charred ghost town over the past year.) That’s my family’s history — but change the names, and you basically have the history of Israel 1.0.”

That generation, Ben-David continued, “made sure their children and grandchildren would understand the importance of preserving Israel as our people’s safe haven, built on democracy and the rule of law.” That priority, that story, “was the thread of steel that has bound each generation to our founding one. It creates a situation that makes Israel unique, and not just in comparison with those who want to annihilate us.”

Look at how “both Ukraine and Russia have had to pass laws to prevent able-bodied men from leaving during war,” he added. “But when Israel is threatened with war, the planes that are full are not with Israelis trying to escape possible hell but with those dropping everything abroad — school, work, vacations — to come home and defend the country, many of whom eventually lose their lives in doing so. You cannot buy that kind of motivation.”

“That steel thread is what has saved us over the decades — and that is exactly what is so dangerous about Netanyahu’s domestic divide-and-conquer strategy that puts his personal interests above all else. Here we are, after the most horrific period in Israel’s history, and Netanyahu keeps snipping away at the thread,” Ben-David wrote. “Aside from encouraging his cultist followers to make state enemies out of hostage families, pilots, physicians and anyone else who dares to criticize the great leader, he has no exit plan for the deepening military crisis, no budget for the deepening economic crisis, no intention of drafting the ultra-Orthodox into an army desperate for manpower to replace all those who we lost. Because all of those might lead his far-right allies to turn against him.”

So on this first anniversary of the Oct. 7 attack, I find myself most preoccupied with the fact that Israel is fighting a multifront war and Israelis still don’t know whether they are fighting to make Israel safe for a Jewish democracy or safe for the prime minister’s political survival, safe for the ultra-Orthodox to never have to serve in the military and safe for the prime minister to declare to the world he is defending the frontier of freedom in Gaza and Lebanon while sustaining a morally rotten and economically draining settlement engine in the West Bank.

The biggest threat to Israel today is not Iran, Hamas, Hezbollah or the Houthis. A united Israel can beat them all. It is those who are unraveling Israel’s steel thread — with a bad story.

Thomas Friedman writes a column for the New York Times.