A federal judge ruled that a man can no longer be detained after he crashed in St. Paul while federal agents were pursuing him.
Immigrations and Customs Enforcement officers were attempting “a targeted vehicle stop” of the 21-year-old man, who is from Honduras and who the U.S. Department of Homeland Security said is in the U.S. illegally.
Officers responded to a report of a crash at 9:40 a.m. Feb. 11 at Western and Selby avenues in the Cathedral Hill neighborhood. The man crashed into two vehicles before hitting a snowbank. He was taken to the hospital with non-life threatening injuries, and people in the other vehicles didn’t report injuries, according to police.
The Trump administration said the goal of Operation Metro Surge was to “target the worst of the worst criminal illegal aliens in the Minneapolis area.” DHS, which usually highlights a person’s criminal record if they have one, did not mention a record for the man in the crash. Court records indicate he has not been convicted of crimes in Minnesota.
DHS said in its statement last week that the man “tried to evade law enforcement and began driving recklessly and ran red lights, endangering public safety and law enforcement.” He had not been federally charged as of Thursday afternoon and it wasn’t known what will happen next with his immigration case.
Police reports document crash
A parent outside Capitol Hill Magnet School, about half a mile from the crash site, reported seeing a Toyota Prius in front of an unmarked vehicle with emergency lights flashing and no sirens on. She said they were “traveling well in excess of the 25 mph speed limit” and estimated them to be going 45-55 mph, according to a St. Paul police report made public Thursday.
A witness at the scene estimated the Prius was traveling 80 to 100 mph and said it went through the intersection without stopping, according to another police report. People saw a man run from the vehicle before federal officers took him into custody.
Federal agents told police that the man had crashed his Prius into their vehicle “but it seemed to be in relation to their pursuit” and not during the crash involving the vehicles at the intersection, a report said.
The man had a revoked driver’s license, according to a police report. No one was cited at the scene.
On Monday in Georgia, a driver fleeing a stop by federal immigration officers crashed into another vehicle, killing a teacher who was headed to work.
Judge orders man’s release
Lauren M. Rossitto of Erickson, Zierke, Kuderer & Madsen, who took on the case as a volunteer attorney for the Minnesota Habeas Project, filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus for the man on Sunday. Such petitions challenge the legal authority of the government to detain someone.
The man contended his detention was “unlawful due to denial of a bond hearing,” Senior U.S. District Judge John M. Gerrard summarized in his order filed Wednesday. “… The government responds that detention is mandatory, not discretionary, and the petitioner is not eligible to be released.”
Attorneys for the U.S. Attorney’s Office and Homeland Security asserted the case was different because the man “was encountered upon entering the country in 2022 and released on recognizance until he was redetained in 2026,” Gerrard summarized.
But Gerrard wrote that the man’s previous detention and release “makes the government’s argument worse, not better. As the court has explained, if the petitioner was at some point an ‘arriving alien,’ but the government decided to release him anyway, that places the petitioner even more firmly into the discretionary detention framework.”
Related Articles
HUD proposes rule that would force noncitizens from public housing
Federal judge accuses Trump administration of ‘terror’ against immigrants in scathing ruling
Lawmaker says the US deported a baby with bronchitis, while authorities say the child was medically cleared
New Trump administration order could lead to the detention of thousands of legal refugees
Justice Dept. lawyer is found in contempt by federal judge in Minnesota
Furthermore, Gerrard said government attorneys “provided neither evidence nor argument that officials have conducted any of the proceedings necessary to revoke a release. … In this case the government hasn’t even produced as much as an administrative warrant.”
Gerrard ordered that if the man had been moved from Minnesota, he should immediately be returned and released from custody. Rossitto had not been able to confirm as of mid-afternoon Thursday if he’d been released. Federal attorneys have until Friday to file a status report showing they complied with the judge’s order.
Many volunteer attorneys, along with the courts, are “working around the clock” on habeas petitions, Rossitto said. “There’s such a volume that we need more help,” she said.
