Sun, Water, Sorrow

posted in: All news | 0

Sonja Vandagriff’s grief was private. She had spoken with a reporter only once in the 10 years since her 24-year-old daughter, Jackie Vandagriff, a nutrition student at Texas Woman’s University, was murdered by a stranger in September 2016. For years, the trauma would routinely overcome her. She’d lie in bed, unable to find a reason to get up now that Jackie’s slightly gap-toothed smile was gone from the Frisco home where she’d both grown up and lived for the last year of her life.

Jackie’s cat, a harlequin tabby named Shay, was clearly also traumatized by her owner’s sudden absence, often watching the front door or lying on Jackie’s old things. Vandagriff learned online that cats mirror human emotions—maybe, she thought, it could work in reverse too: Make the tabby happy, and her own spirits would lift. In 2023, she planted a native plant, the American beautyberry, outside her front window to attract butterflies and birds. She called it “Cat TV,” and it seemed to do wonders for Shay’s mood. And Vandagriff had stumbled on a new way to channel her grief, eventually deciding to expand from that first shrub to a full garden—a “homegrown national park” that became her new purpose. 

“I was hanging by a thread for seven years, and when I started this garden, I used what I had to build it. And what I had was grief energy,” she told the Texas Observer in July, sitting under an umbrella on her small back patio, overlooking the garden she’d put years of this energy into. She luxuriated in her pocket of calm amid the beeps of garbage trucks, the shouts of construction crews, and other mainstays of the suburban soundscape. 

Sonja Vandagriff discovers Gulf fritillary caterpillars resting on the leaves of her passion flower vines in late September.

Her corner of North Texas is situated in the last remaining stretch of Blackland Prairie—much of it having been paved over and developed—where rich clay soil makes for perfect growing of Shumard oaks, sumac, sage, and wildflowers that attract pollinators. Here, suburban yards become home to raccoons, cottontails, great horned owls, blue jays, and Texas spiny lizards, among other species. 

Vandagriff’s house, in the northern Dallas suburbs, sits in the middle of a large manicured neighborhood, but not far from a creek that feeds a lush stretch of trees, a massive ranch, and a city-managed 5-acre wildflower meadow. Up to this point, her backyard had been standard: a medley of grasses, an oak tree, and some partially inhabited planters. But she was suddenly galvanized. She ordered a heap of wood chips and began to build a native habitat. 

The process instilled in Vandagriff a sort of evangelical zeal about native plants and animals, but still, she stayed under the radar, sharing her passion and story only with her small community. Her grief stayed private, but now it had a physical form, a place where she’d laid her energy and watched it transform into something beautiful. 

She was content to keep quiet, until she learned her efforts could be threatened by a potential development 600 miles away. Now, she realized she had something to speak up about. 

Earlier this year, Vandagriff learned of an ongoing court battle attempting to halt the federal government’s plan to give nearly 730 acres of public land to SpaceX, the aerospace company led by billionaire Elon Musk, to expand around its Boca Chica launch site, where it’s been operating since 2014. The land in question is currently part of the Lower Rio Grande Valley National Wildlife Refuge, home to myriad species: 1,200 types of plants, 300 butterflies, and about 700 vertebrates, according to its website.

Get the newsletter

Sign up for The Lede

Get the stories you need to know about each week. Delivered every Sunday.

The swath in question has degraded over the past decade, in part due to SpaceX’s activity in the area. Post-launch analyses have found that some rocket launches have caused debris including concrete and metal to rain down on the refuge. 

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS), which manages the land, contends that it’s best to give the land over to the company in exchange for some of the company’s land in the area, which hasn’t been as affected by the rocket activity, to be part of a separate refuge—sort of like a homeowner handing over their keys to a destructive neighbor and moving down the street to a harder-to-access house. 

“Through the proposed exchange, [FWS] would divest of lands likely to be impacted by SpaceX activities, and SpaceX would exchange land that includes desirable habitat for conservation,” the government agency explains on its website. In June, several nonprofits filed a federal lawsuit in an attempt to quash the land swap. A judge denied their request for a preliminary injunction to halt the swap in September, possibly clearing the path for the trade.

Vandagriff told the Observer she’s desperate for the deal to be stopped or reversed somehow, and she’s particularly worried about one species of visitor to her garden. In the fall, Vandagriff can sit in a chair on her patio in North Texas and see up to 50 monarch butterflies at once as they make their trip south. They love the milkweed Vandagriff has planted and the native mulberry tree that popped up on its own once she had restored the soil. She fears this development along the monarchs’ migratory path could threaten their survival. “I like my monarchs,” she said. “They’re the treat in my garden.”

Vandagriff stands in her garden.

The large orange-and-black butterflies are the state insect of Texas (and of several other states). They’re also one of the world’s longest-haul migratory species, making a trip from Canada to Mexico every fall, then back up every spring. They travel the middle of the United States along a path that has been repeatedly interrupted by climate change and development. The plants they need to reproduce are falling to herbicides, the trees they rest in during the winter are being felled, and roads and buildings are creating dangerous obstacles in their way. And a warming planet makes the butterflies vulnerable to infections. In 2024, the federal government proposed monarchs as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act, meaning they’re likely to become endangered in the near future.

Kristen Baum, director of Monarch Watch, a project out of the University of Kansas, said it’s difficult to predict the implications of particular projects, but the Lower Rio Grande Valley “is important to monarchs in both the fall and spring.”

Because monarchs need food and places to lay their eggs as they journey, “nectar and milkweed availability in Texas is critical to the monarch’s annual cycle, and conditions in Texas can strongly influence the overall size of the monarch population in any given year,” she said. 

FWS published an environmental assessment of the land swap and found that it would have “no significant impact,” while still acknowledging that threatened and endangered species could be at further risk “through reduction in foraging, dispersal, or breeding habitat quantity and/or quality; mortality due to vehicle collisions; displacement or alteration of behavior due to disturbances from light and/or noise; and exposure to hazardous chemicals from heavy machinery used during construction.”

The government further argued, according to court documents, that the development “will result in foreseeable and unavoidable consequences” but that there would be a “net conservation benefit.”

Vandagriff, however, sees writing on the wall. With the deal, she said, “I can start saying goodbye to my monarchs. And I’m going to have to say goodbye, again, to something that I love? I’m done saying goodbye to things I love.” 

On July 23, I pull up in front of Vandagriff’s house in the North Texas suburb of Frisco as early as I can muster. She’s called the previous day to move our scheduled 10 a.m. interview up because of the heat. She gets up by 5 each morning, so we had plenty of time to work with. I arrive at 8, and the unsweetened, half-caf iced tea begins flowing. 

“There’s no such thing as too much tea,” she assures me as she refills my glass. 

Vandagriff, in her early 60s, has her hair pulled back in a ponytail. She’s wearing a color-blocked dress, an apron, knee-high knit socks, and bright red gardening boots. 

Her childhood home was on a half-acre wooded lot in Beavercreek, Ohio. “It was like we lived in a park,” she says. In a sunny patch, her dad planted a garden that exploded with raspberries and tomatoes and strawberries. Vandagriff would help in the garden, then she’d assist with the haul. They’d can tomatoes and make jam. “In the dead of winter, we would open up a raspberry preserve jar, and summer would come back to us.”

While she and her husband raised their two daughters, Vandagriff worked as a professional cook, teaching culinary classes for kids and working as the resident chef at Market Street in McKinney. She always had herbs growing somewhere nearby, but she dreamed of expanding her garden.

For the most part, she’s self-driven and self-taught. She knows Turk’s-cap and lemon balm can grow harmoniously together, while the former will crowd out any other herbs she tries to plant nearby. She discovered this the hard way. She discovered something else, too, through trial, error, and observation: Nature likes paths. Ants march in lines, following pheromone trails. Monarch butterflies migrate by orienting themselves using the sun and magnetic field. Sometimes you can discern the path Vandagriff likes to walk in the house, because she’ll track dirt in from her garden. 

Vandagriff noticed Shay would follow the same paths every time she went out into the garden. When she looked into why, she found out that trails are ubiquitous—her yard sits on a trail that connects to the nearby Panther Creek, and, of course, on the trail, the monarchs follow in their biannual pilgrimage. 

“I discovered that the garden is really kind of an Airbnb for insects,” she says. “There are some that do live here, but most of the wildlife in my garden is just passing through. It’s just making a pit stop.”

Vandagriff

She puts a lot of work into maintaining this waystation, but she also welcomes help. The garden has shown her she’s not as physically capable as she once was. She has to reckon with the realities of arthritis, frequent back injuries, and old aches flaring up. 

Her daughter’s friends are among those who started coming over to help Vandagriff distribute rainwater, remove non-native plants, and deadhead spent blooms, all tasks that always need doing. It’s become part of a grieving process for all of them.

“They grew up in my house, they had sleepovers here, they’ve been my witnesses and my partners,” she says. “They’re healing too, because they’re devastated by Jackie’s loss.”

Jackie was a junior in college when she was killed by a man she’d just met—who was later caught and convicted—in an act of violence that left everyone shaken and unsure how to move forward. She’d been a compassionate, driven, and friendly young woman whose enthusiasm for wellness motivated her to pursue her major in nutrition. 

Vandagriff says Jackie would be in the backyard helping too if she were still around. It would have aligned with her passion for health, and she would have loved to see her mom’s drive, which she took as inspiration in her own life.

“There is a twinge of like, ‘Ugh, Jackie would have loved this.’ She would have loved it,” she says. “My life is all about accepting the idea of bittersweet moments.”

By channeling her grief into her garden, Vandagriff is following a long tradition of finding solace in nature. Heidi Schreiber-Pan, psychotherapist and author of Nature’s Healing Power Unveiled, said that nature helps quiet bad thoughts and preoccupation because “there’s so much sensory-rich information. There’s colors, there’s movement, there is sound.” 

Vandagriff’s garden helps ground her, but it also has reach. Vandagriff has grown several plants in honor of other mothers whose children have died, many of whom also have what they call “grief gardens,” where they work through their loss. 

“We’re not gonna let these kids be forgotten,” she says. “We could do a statue, we could do a marker, but what about a plant? A living memorial.” 

Vandagriff’s native garden, then, is a cat entertainment center, a reason to get out of bed in the morning, and a collection of life in honor of others who died too soon. Primarily, it’s a place where she can trade her grief energy for purpose, and she shares the space happily.

In her life, Vandagriff has experienced the cruelty of fate, the unfairness of living in pain as the result of someone else’s actions, someone who likely didn’t consider the ripple effects of his callousness. But the garden has given her a sense of agency—and urgency. 

“If I have any control at all over not saying goodbye to the monarchs, then I use it,” she says. “I’m not going to say goodbye to them because someone decided that they weren’t worth it or that they didn’t count. What counts is one butterfly on one flower. That counts.” 

The post Sun, Water, Sorrow appeared first on The Texas Observer.

Data Centers and Gambling Show How Power Works at the Texas Capitol

posted in: All news | 0

Heading into the 2027 legislative session, two issues are almost certain to get marquee billing at the Texas Capitol. One is the speculative rush of hyperscaler data center development all across the state.  The other is gambling—what activity that covers, whether it should be legalized and to what extent. 

Both are polarizing issues with heavyweight political lobbies behind them. They also both provide lessons in how the Texas Legislature and the powers that be go about governing (or not) on major policy in the second-largest state in the union. 

With data centers, Texas now finds itself at the center of a historic land rush, with hundreds of potential projects that will suck up gobs of electricity, water, and acreage. The Legislature saw this coming, and it opened up a permissive structure for such “large-load” projects by passing Senate Bill 6 in the 2025 session. Then came the flood of massive projects led by Google, Stargate, and others. Governor Greg Abbott now-infamously declared Texas the “epicenter” of AI development. But in the scramble to make Texas a data center destination, lawmakers showed little forethought. 

It’s an example of how the GOP-led Lege prioritized unfettered business and economic development over time-consuming policy consideration. Gambling, meanwhile, is a contrary example of how the Legislature, in its decidedly finite wisdom, has rightly avoided the rush to legalize. Lured by the promise of easy tax revenue, red and blue states around the country have scrambled to turn their turf into digital (and physical) casinos. 

Get the newsletter

Sign up for The Lede

Get the stories you need to know about each week. Delivered every Sunday.

Both are roughly 80-20 issues, though inverted: In the case of legalizing sports betting and casino gambling, the masses are broadly supportive, and with data centers, the masses are broadly against. But, in both instances, the opposing interests hold a big stick. 

Data center interests, Big Tech firms, and the ancillary players have staked their prospects on the lucrative and potentially destructive future of artificial intelligence, which requires the rapid and uninhibited development of computing power housed in sprawling warehouses. 

And with gambling, while there are powerful interests on the side of the masses—the casino moguls and online sports betting giants, whose interests are differing but largely aligned—there are equally powerful interests holding the line against legalization. Those include religious social conservatives, who long had a champion in Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick, who firmly blocked pro-gambling bills from even getting a hearing in his Senate, and casino operators in bordering states like Oklahoma and Louisiana. 

At the fore of the casino lobby is Las Vegas Sands, owned by megadonor Miriam Adelson (wife of the late mogul Sheldon). The company is the most well-represented of any at the Capitol, with a small army of over 80 lobbyists on retainer. Adelson and Sands’ PAC have also plied practically every legislator with a pulse and every legislative caucus with a member with hefty campaign checks. 

The other pro-gambling cohort includes those trying to legalize online sports betting—led by the industry titans DraftKings and FanDuel. They’ve formed a coalition called the Sports Betting Alliance, which includes Rick Perry as a hired gun and has its own lengthy roster of lobbyists. 

Thus far, despite the pro-gambling interests’ vast resources and built-in public support, they’ve made little progress. Early on, they got Abbott to at least say he’s not opposed to casinos on principle, and they seemingly got majority support in the House. But Lieutenant Dan was remarkably immovable on the issue, though he hedged by saying it was his Senate members who weren’t interested in taking a vote on it. That at least created room to move if necessary. 

Texas’ legislative resistance has left it as one of the top remaining state targets. Since the United States Supreme Court opened the door in 2018, 31 states have legalized online sports betting, and another handful have allowed such gambling at brick-and-mortar locations. 

The selling point for allowing sports betting (or casinos) is that it would bring in billions of dollars in tax revenue on wagers that are otherwise going to neighboring states or being made on the black market. Still, in the big states that have opened up gambling, the relative share of tax revenue has been small: The average state share of gambling income accounts for just 0.2 percent of total tax revenue. Meanwhile, the downsides of putting a digital bookie in every resident’s pocket have proved numerous and substantial. In pursuit of never-ending market penetration, sports betting and other forms of gambling have invaded nearly every corner of popular culture. 

While it may fly in the face of liberal orthodoxy—Democrats, including James Talarico, are broadly supportive of expanding legal gambling—conservative anti-gambling forces in Texas actually look rather prescient for holding the line. And Texas may have a chance to get even more proactive against new forms of profit speculation.  

The Senate signaled a potential crackdown next session on so-called prediction markets, including Kalshi and Polymarket. Whether those entities are exploiting a loophole in state law to engage in otherwise illegal betting was made an interim charge for the upper chamber. 

These platforms have expanded fast in states like Texas, arguing that they are not engaging in gambling but “peer-to-peer” prediction contracts—similar to, say, futures commodities. These companies argue that they are adequately regulated by the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission and that any attempt by states to regulate these markets is preempted by the feds. 

Still, Texas legislators have indicated they intend to take them on. “We can dress it up, call it this, call it that, whatever it is,” GOP state Senator Bob Hall said. “The bottom line is, it is gambling. It’s illegal, and we have to figure out a way to make sure the people understand it and put an end to it.” Both Kalshi and Polymarket have begun to assemble a stable of lobbyists to rep their interests at the Capitol. 

In the face of mounting opposition to data centers—which reached a fever pitch over the summer—state leaders at first opted to keep their heads down, expecting the outrage to be fleeting. Then they tried changing the conversation. And when that didn’t work, finally, the governor pointed the finger at industry and used his unilateral executive power to hit the emergency brake by ordering up an “audit” of the hundreds of proposed data center projects that were in the queue to hook up to the grid, ensuring that they meet certain arbitrary criteria—including covering the cost of new infrastructure, limiting water usage, and so forth. Almost every single entity with a hand in the data center boom came out in laudatory favor of the good governor’s order—of course, always the mark of quality industry regulation. 

Conveniently, that audit was going to take the inundated regulators at the Texas Public Utility Commission (PUC) until after the election to complete. Then what? Abbott largely glossed over that question. (Environmental regulators have resumed review of data center permits, the Texas Tribune reported this week.) This was a classic part of Abbott’s governing playbook: to handle (certain) policy issues during the interim (and beyond), use his expansive executive authority to dictate policy himself via the state agencies, delay and draw things out till after Election Day, and ultimately marginalize the role of the Legislature. 

The big players like this sort of regulation because the cost of compliance will thin out the competition, quell some of the populist backlash, and create a preordained landscape upon which they’ll direct the Lege to enshrine this into law. 

Abbott’s executive dictates, and that of the PUC, were likely intended to serve as the basis on which the Legislature would write regulatory bills. Typically, it’s supposed to be the other way around, but that increasingly was not the case as Abbott expanded the bounds of his executive power. 

On data centers, where the governor took over, Abbott wagged the dog. On gambling, where the governor largely stayed on the sidelines, Patrick, whether through stubbornness or foresight, effectively wagged his finger. 

The Democratic takeover of the governor’s mansion and the state House—though not the state Senate—may have legalized-gambling advocates optimistic, but there’s still plenty of time for the new, unanticipated regime to decide exactly how it wants to break with the past.

The post Data Centers and Gambling Show How Power Works at the Texas Capitol appeared first on The Texas Observer.

Solitary Confinement Kills, and Texas Knows It

posted in: All news | 0

Here is what you do not hear in a Texas prison at two in the morning: a crisis counselor. A mental health worker. A trained voice asking whether you are safe. What you hear is concrete. You hear the sound of your own thinking, which in solitary confinement is the most dangerous sound of all. I am incarcerated in the Texas Department of Criminal Justice (TDCJ) system, and I am telling you this because Brooklyn Hogrell is dead, and she did not have to be.

Brooklyn grew up in Texas. She was 21 years old when she died at Mountain View, a TDCJ women’s facility, in April of 2024. She had survived childhood rape and molestation, had been processed through the state’s juvenile justice system, had fought back against a system that called her trauma aggression and responded with restraints that triggered her flashbacks of abuse, as her mother later told me. She had made her way to a lower-security housing unit at Lane Murray, earned job promotions, and been building something that looked like momentum. Then she was sent to solitary after defending herself from an attack, her mom said, transferred to a facility that stripped away the programs and counseling she had accessed, and placed with a cell neighbor who had spent months threatening her life. The prison placed them facing each other. Brooklyn had spoken to her mother ten times a day until that transfer made those calls nearly impossible. The counselor’s last entry read: “follow-up in one week.” Brooklyn died before that week passed.

I know these details because I know this system, and I know how its silences work. I know what it means when the mental health appointment is scheduled for next Tuesday and the crisis arrives on Saturday night. I know what it means to be inside a cell with no way to reach a human voice that doesn’t belong to a correctional officer whose job is custody, not care. I know what it means to have a thought you cannot say out loud to anyone in uniform, because saying it out loud results in punitive suicide watch, not help.

Get the newsletter

Sign up for The Lede

Get the stories you need to know about each week. Delivered every Sunday.

The Texas Civil Rights Project, in partnership with the University of Texas School of Law’s Civil Rights Clinic, published a 2023 report called “Solitary Confinement in Texas: A Crisis with No End.” That report found that the suicide rate in Texas facilities between 2020 and 2022 was 86 percent higher than the average rate for all United States prisons in 2019. It documented conditions described as grotesque, including human waste on cell walls and cells infested with insects. It urged the federal Department of Justice to open an inquiry. Brooklyn had been living inside these conditions for years. The Texas Observer documented earlier data from the Texas Civil Rights Project showing that seven of the 35 prisoners who died by suicide in 2017 were housed in isolation, and five suicides inside Texas prisons in the year that followed occurred in solitary confinement.

Solitary kills, and Texas knows it. It has known it for years. It continues, because the people dying in those cells are not people the institution has any structural incentive to keep alive beyond the minimum required by litigation and oversight that arrives too late.

The 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline exists. It is a three-digit number that connects a caller to a trained crisis counselor at any hour of the day or night. A JAMA study published in April found that between July 2022 and December 2024, about 35,500 people ages 15 to 34 died by suicide, compared to a projected 39,900, meaning the hotline is credibly associated with thousands of lives saved. The State of Washington implemented 988 access for its incarcerated population in 2024. Prison mental health staff are often not available after business hours, and the Washington Office of the Corrections Ombuds recognized that providing a way for people to talk with a trained crisis counselor anonymously, with reduced potential for suicide watch placement, and after hours could be helpful in reducing suicide attempts and deaths.

TDCJ will resist this. The agency has resisted every reform anyone has ever proposed. It will cite security concerns, implementation costs, and the administrative complexity of extending phone access in restrictive housing. What it will not cite is the name of every person who has died in one of its cells after hours, when no one with the training to help was anywhere to be found. I can say with certainty that the security risk of a crisis line is smaller than the body count of its absence. (TDCJ did not respond to a Texas Observer request for comment.)

I have been inside long enough to know that the women who die in these facilities are not mysteries. They are patterns. They are women who came in already broken, who got more broken here, who asked for help in the ways broken people ask for it: by fighting, by covering their cell windows, by cutting, by crying into walls. Brooklyn asked for help every way she knew how to ask. Her mother asked for her. The system answered with a transfer and a notation. Next week.

Since I first started this essay, I was placed back in solitary confinement myself, where I previously spent almost nine years. Not because I broke a rule but “for my own protection.” My cellmate, a woman with serious mental illness, became violent and threatened me. The prison’s solution was to lock me alone in a solitary cell for a week in August.

That cell is Brooklyn’s old cell.

I can still see traces of her. Marks left behind. Small reminders that another young woman lived here before me, terrified and alone. This is where she spent her final days. This is where Texas now tells me I will be “protected.”

Texas has a choice it keeps refusing to make. It can treat the lives of incarcerated women as worth a phone line, or it can keep filling out the paperwork after those women are gone. Brooklyn’s paperwork is already done. The question is whose name comes next—and whether anyone in Austin will decide that the next death is worth preventing.

The post Solitary Confinement Kills, and Texas Knows It appeared first on The Texas Observer.

South Texas Town Privately Supported LNG Development After Publicly Opposing It, Emails Reveal

posted in: All news | 0

In the summer of 2015, dozens of residents from the Laguna Madre area came to Laguna Vista’s city hall, in the coastal border town of around 4,000 between Los Fresnos and Port Isabel. The quiet, bay-facing suburb was now contending with yet another thing that would change the community forever: liquefied natural gas (LNG) plants to be developed a few miles away, near Port Isabel where many of the town’s residents work or go to school. The year prior, Elon Musk’s SpaceX had broken ground at nearby Boca Chica Beach. 

These plants would turn gas from Eagle Ford Shale deposits into liquid methane then ship it all over the world, supplying electric power to countries in Asia and Europe. Built along the Brownsville Ship Channel, massive tanker ships filled with the gas would traverse the man-made waterway in and out of the Gulf of Mexico multiple times a day. Storage tanks would be built across a Central Park-sized area of wetlands, with at least three facilities planned at that time. One of those projects would later be abandoned.

These facilities would be the first of their kind in the area, the closest like them hundreds of miles up the coastline in Freeport and Port Arthur. Those cities, inundated with the consequences of industrial booms and busts, were a telling sign for the Laguna Madre area—which, at the southeastern edge of the Rio Grande Valley, includes touristy South Padre Island as well—where no petrochemical industry had set up shop outside of the infrastructure already inside the Port of Brownsville, much of that being chemical and oil storage. (Even that kind of storage hadn’t been in the area in several decades, long abandoned.) 

Laguna Madre residents—who mostly work in the area’s tourism and fishing industries and are 90 percent Latino, according to Census data—overtly didn’t want it, which is why they showed up en masse to that 2015 council meeting in Laguna Vista, where officials were set to vote on whether to adopt an official resolution opposing LNG plants in the area.

“[Laguna Vista] had to hold it outside because there were too many people within City Hall,” Diane Teter, a retired biology professor and member of the advocacy group Save RGV from LNG, who lived in Laguna Vista at the time, told the Texas Observer. 

“We have received a request from one of our large investors asking about Laguna Vista’s support for the project.”

Laguna Vista officials fielded at least two hours of public comments about how the projects could harm the health of people and the environment—and about residents’ bewilderment at why the companies wanted their taxes abated. One council member recused herself because she was a paid ambassador of Houston-based NextDecade’s Rio Grande LNG, the largest of the two projects vying to operate in the area.

Afterward, the mayor, Susie Houston, and the rest of the council unanimously passed the resolution in opposition, which was submitted to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) as that agency solicited public comments from residents, a process triggered by the LNG companies applying for operating permits. 

“The economy of the Laguna Madre Area is heavily-dependent on tourism and fishing industries, which rely upon the natural resources within the area,” the resolution states. “In addition to the environmental, economic, quality of life and safety concerns connected with the proposed construction of LNG facilities, the proposal also raises questions of environmental justice, given that the proposed facilities are to be located in close proximity to a community comprised of ethnic minorities and persons of low to moderate income.”

The following day, the City of South Padre Island would pass its own similar resolution. Port Isabel, meanwhile, had submitted its opposition to FERC a week earlier, uniting the Laguna Madre area’s local governments.

More than a decade later, the South Padre Island and Port Isabel governments remain opposed to LNG development in the area, as the much larger city of Brownsville and surrounding Cameron County have become ardent political supporters of NextDecade’s Rio Grande LNG project, which is set to process its first batch of methane next year. NextDecade plans to eventually expand Rio Grande LNG to ten trains–the machinery that converts gas into liquid methane–processing more of the fuel type than any other facility in the world. 

Now, the Observer is reporting for the first time, NextDecade also found a covert ally in recent years in Laguna Vista, as emails obtained through a records request show. 

Despite its public opposition, these records show, the small city solicited event sponsorships and pursued the possibility of NextDecade developing a medical facility in the town. Rendie Gonzales, then the city manager of Laguna Vista, became the main point of contact between the town and the LNG company as it broke ground in the summer of 2023 and into late 2024, when Gonzales was fired by the town in a unanimous council decision that December. Gonzales did not respond to the Observer’s repeated requests for comment for this story. 

The emails released to the Observer, which are dated from August 30, 2023, to December 19, 2025, show NextDecade’s former chief lobbyist, David Keane, and its current Director of Community Relations Andrea Benton corresponding with Gonzales numerous times. The earliest of these emails shows Gonzales asking Laguna Vista police department officials to attend a NextDecade transportation and traffic committee meeting—an offshoot of the firm’s “Community Advisory Board” (CAB), which consists mostly of elected officials who support the project—and asking NextDecade to sponsor or table at events hosted by the town. 

“I’d love to see you guys here and Laguna Vista be able to take part in the positive promotion of this great opportunity for our area(s),” Gonzales wrote to Keane and Benton on September 26, 2023. 

NextDecade invited Gonzales and the town council to Rio Grande LNG’s groundbreaking a few days later, in October 2023. Two council members, Theresa Bryant and Bettina Tolin, and the town’s police chief, Tony David, would attend the groundbreaking alongside several other Rio Grande Valley elected officials and business leaders. Gonzales, who planned to go, would end up missing the event, she later wrote to Keane.

“I’d love to take you and Andrea to an [sic] I am sorry I missed the opening lunch and catch up if you guys are available,” Gonzales said in an email on October 10, 2023. 

Tolin, the former councilmember, was invited to that lunch, too, which was had at Laguna Vista’s golf course restaurant a few days later, according to the emails. Tolin told the Observer she had been an early supporter of the project (she was not yet on council at the time of the 2015 opposition vote) and a member of what would later become NextDecade’s CAB.

“It was clear to me that [LNG] was coming to our town,” Tolin, who is now a realtor in the San Antonio area, said. “They were genuinely, from the very beginning, and I believe they still are now, concerned about what the community felt about the project. They went to great lengths from the very beginning to ensure that everyone in the community–business owners, citizens, people–knew what was happening.” 

The Rio Grande LNG site as seen from the Brownsville Ship Channel in February (Gaige Davila/Texas Observer)

Tolin told the Observer that she had suggested to Gonzales to connect with NextDecade, pointing to Brownsville’s now-former City Manager Helen Ramirez and her involvement in the company’s various committees that examined how Rio Grande LNG would impact the communities near it. Emails show that Gonzales had at least four in-person meetings with one or both of the NextDecade employees before her firing in late 2024. 

“This is such an important project/journey to the community and I know I want to make sure Laguna Vista is involved in whatever we can be to help ensure the success of this project and the impact it holds for our community,” Gonzales wrote to Keane on January 8, 2024. 

That same month, on January 18, she sent Keane an email asking for the company’s help to develop land facing the highway that connects the Laguna Madre area’s communities. 

“There are a few ideas I want to kick around regarding the development in LV off of Hwy. 100 and I feel that MAYBE there might be some partnership opportunities with NextDecade/LNG,” Gonzales wrote. “Even if it doesn’t have that possibility I do value your insight, respect how you conduct yourself and your team, and you have a lot of experience with seeing big projects from early stages into fruition so even if I can just enlist you as a mentor I would be forever grateful.”

A month later, Keane would bring up Laguna Vista’s 2015 resolution opposing LNG development in the area.  

“We have received a request from one of our large investors asking about Laguna Vista’s support for the project. They raised the point about Laguna Vista’s City Council passing a resolution several years ago that opposed the Rio Grande LNG project,” Keane wrote to Gonzales in a February 14, 2024, email. “I tell them that they [sic] situation has changed and we now have strong support for the project by the city.” 

Keane then asked Gonzales for “something from [her] stating the support.” Gonzales responded saying she didn’t know whether there had been a resolution. 

“I thought I [sic] had told me that we didn’t pass anything, in support of or in opposition to,” Gonzales wrote. Keane said the company wouldn’t need a letter if there had been no resolution, but Gonzales said she would check with the mayor. The Observer acquired a copy of the original resolution from FERC’s eLibrary system, where it has been filed since September 2015.

Gonzales forwarded Keane’s question to current Laguna Vista Mayor Mike Carter the same day.

“I had been given the advice to not put anything controversial on the agenda during election time so tell me your thoughts on Mr. Keane’s email below requesting a Resolution in Support of LNG,” Gonzales wrote. “LNG … support will come in very handy in our pursuit to build an emergency room on Hwy. 100. I have spoken to Mr. Keane about it already and he feels it’s a great idea and offered to help along the way etc. I understand the issue of the LNG plant coming was an issue; however, they are here now and their partnership could be of great value to Laguna Vista in the coming years and development. Not to mention the residents who will be living/moving here who work at and for LNG. Let me know.”

The emails obtained by the Observer do not include any response from Carter. He also did not respond to requests for comment or a written list of questions. Neither did Victor Treviño, the current city manager of Laguna Vista.

People fishing along Highway 48 in December 2024, the Rio Grande LNG’s construction site in the distance (Gaige Davila)

In May 2024, Keane sent talking points highlighting Rio Grande LNG to members of the CAB, which included Gonzales, asking that members speak in favor of the project’s request for a tax abatement extension with Cameron County. Tolin would attend the June 2024 hearing and speak in favor of the project. It’s unclear whether Gonzales attended the hearing. 

The following month, Gonzales sent the email addresses of two area realtors, Olga Vega-Carter and Eliot Carter, to Keane and Benton, offering a connection for NextDecade employees relocating to Laguna Vista.

“We wanted to touch base with you and see if there is anything LNG/Next-Decade/Bechtel [the construction contractor for the Rio Grande LNG project] need in order to help transition their teams to the great Laguna Vista area,” Gonzales wrote. “In addition, I thought it would be beneficial for Mr. Carter to sit in on the Housing Advisory Committee in order to help represent Laguna Vista in this aspect of the LNG project. Laguna Vista, as you know, is a wonderful and growing community that could become home to many involved in this project and we would love to help in any way we can.”

Gonzales did not disclose in the email that the realtors are the wife and son of Laguna Vista’s mayor, Carter. The Observer could not determine whether any NextDecade or Bechtel employees used the realtors to relocate to the area.

“Some of our colleagues are already enjoying Laguna Vista, and I’m sure more will follow,” Benton wrote back. 

The same week that NextDecade had its FERC permit vacated by a federal appeals court citing insufficient environmental analysis, in August 2024, Gonzales asked for data to help her back up NextDecade against skeptical residents. 

“I was having a conversation this morning with a resident who pushed back on our ‘local residents’ employed,” Gonzales wrote on August 7. “They are under the impression that these numbers are fabricated that they aren’t actual ‘locals’ rather they are people that have moved here for this job and therefore are being considered ‘locals’. Is there a way to get some back up data / information that would help depict that information?”

Benton wrote back that only employees who have residences within 100 miles of Rio Grande LNG are counted as local hires and that Rio Grande LNG’s construction site director lived in Laguna Vista.

“Also, he pointed out that although he moved from Houston, both of his children now attend local schools, and they are now ‘locals,’ just like many of the residents of Laguna Vista, who moved from another area at some point and made this town their home,” Benton wrote on August 14, 2024.

Keane wrote: “One thing I would add is that about 80 to 90% of the workers (our observation and we are working to confirm) on site are Hispanic, which the very people the Sierra Club and Port Isabel [whose lawsuit led to Rio Grande LNG’s FERC permit being vacated] are seeking to protect. If the Court decision is upheld these people are out of work. How is this protecting the environmental justice community?”

In November 2024, Gonzales would attend a luncheon in Brownsville alongside Keane, Benton, and Brownsville’s mayor and city manager receiving executives from Mitsubishi UFJ, a global Japan-based bank and a major financier of the Rio Grande LNG project. 

NextDecade would sponsor at least two town events in 2024 and another in 2025, totalling $2,500. The company would also give Laguna Vista a support letter for a federal grant that the town was applying for in 2025, in hopes of developing a “Regional Emergency Operations Center and Public Safety Facility” in the area, akin to a similar project currently being constructed for the City of Brownsville. The letter was not included in the town’s release of emails to the Observer. 

NextDecade has spent years lobbying elected officials, business owners, and other community leaders to support Rio Grande LNG, particularly after it broke ground on the facility in 2023. The company has successfully gotten the backing of the area’s chambers of commerce and has even tried to curry favor with people like Teter, the retired biology professor, who said that the company was seeking her support because of her science background. She declined to speak with the firm’s representatives. 

“During my years in the Lower Valley, I got the impression that environmentalists felt they had more influence and that their voices were being heard more clearly,” Rolando Vela, who was the city manager of Laguna Vista from 2010 to 2019, wrote in an email to the Observer. “With SpaceX’s arrival and the growing presence of LNG projects, I think their voices have gradually been overshadowed, and their influence has weakened.”

Vela, who is now the general manager of Cameron County Drainage District #5, continued: “Back then, a majority of City Council members were strongly opposed to anything they believed might negatively affect the environment. I think remnants of that sentiment still exist today, but it is not as pronounced as it once was. Environmental concerns remain part of the conversation, but the current political climate at both the state and national levels has made it more challenging for environmental advocates to be heard and to influence decisions.”

NextDecade’s lobbying efforts have proceeded in a time when experts globally point to the LNG market’s instability and how dangerous the liquefaction facilities are to public health and the environment. 

One of those experts, Terence Garrett, a retired political scientist who taught at the University of Texas Rio Grande Valley and has researched how the projects will affect the Laguna Madre area, has lived in Laguna Vista since the town passed the resolution against LNG development. 

Like many residents at the time, he attended the various meetings hosted by the Laguna Madre-area cities and agencies soliciting public comment from residents. Now, 11 years later, the opposition isn’t the same. He said that NextDecade has the money and influence to build support for Rio Grande LNG when opposing organizations have little of either.

“They’re able to also do public relations and eventually sway people over, even if initially they weren’t even in favor of it,” Garrett told the Observer, referring to NextDecade sponsoring longtime events in the area like the Causeway Run. “They can wait us out, and they have the money.” 

Near proposed South Texas LNG site, August 2021 (Ivan Armando Flores/Texas Observer)

Garrett’s concerns about LNG processing in the Laguna Madre area have grown as Rio Grande LNG gets closer to finishing construction. While Brownsville-based governments continue to solicit more militarized industry to the area, he’s increasingly concerned about an LNG storage tank becoming a target of terrorism. 

“We’re not safe anywhere around here,” he said on a video call from his Laguna Vista home. “It’s like a seven-megaton bomb equivalent, if they hit a tank full of liquefied natural gas, and so that is distressing.” 

NextDecade did not respond to a request for comment for this story. 

Tolin, who told the Observer that her place on NextDecade’s CAB was as a business owner in Port Isabel and not as a Laguna Vista council member, said that NextDecade’s relationship with Laguna Vista was not notable during her time—about four years in all—with the town. She mentioned that the company had presented during a town council meeting at least once but otherwise was not a regular topic for the town’s government.

“We knew they existed, and it was not in our power or desire to stop them,” she said. “Everybody in the community had an opinion about it, and they probably still do. Some people think it’s great; some people think it’s terrible. It’s like anything in politics, right? But it wasn’t something that we spent a lot of time talking about.” 

Teter, who moved about an hour and a half away from Laguna Vista to Edinburg in 2017, partly because of fear of both LNG and SpaceX operations nearby, said the town’s behind-the-scenes switch to supporting gas processing in the area was part of a larger cultural shift of business and politics in the Rio Grande Valley.

“We’re seeing a major change in this area. It’s becoming an aerospace, industrial, military complex right there … and then we’ve got the most erratic space cowboy on the coast with SpaceX,” said Teter. “We’re moving into a warlike community rather than peace. So, the changes that you see here [in the Valley] are now the changes that are going to reflect what we are in the future.”

As of November 2026, Laguna Vista’s town council has still taken no official action rescinding its 2015 opposition to LNG or expressing support for the fossil fuel projects.

Gonzales, after her firing, was employed as city administrator for the City of Palm Valley, near Harlingen. She was fired by that city council in June of this year following reported disagreements with the local police chief. Keane retired from NextDecade last April.

The post South Texas Town Privately Supported LNG Development After Publicly Opposing It, Emails Reveal appeared first on The Texas Observer.